Hear about new posts as they happen. Improve your marketing.

Today I want to show you a new tool that we published recently onsite: the SEO calculator.

I’m excited about this tool because it works towards answering a question that we get asked all the freaking time:

How much should I expect to pay for SEO?

This question is so hard to answer because there are so many different factors that go into it:

Here’s how it looks:

SEO calculator screenshot


Let’s talk about some of the answers it generates and some of the objections I have heard raised (other than that it doesn’t work on mobile, which that fix is in progress). Also, don’t forget to cross reference it with our average SEO hourly rates and digital marketing industry pricing survey publications. And if you think the price given is wrong, please email your objections to hello@getcredo.com.

It says I should pay half of my revenue for SEO

Sometimes the calculator will spit out a number that seems incredibly high for the business that you have.

As an example, if you say that you have a site with:

  • Under 500 pages
  • 1,000-10,000 visits per month
  • Under $10,000 a year in revenue
  • Want to grow by 50%
  • An advertising business model

the calculator will say that you should expect to pay (plus or minus 20%) $1,725 per month for SEO help.

That’s outrageous!” you’ll say.

Over 12 months that’s more than my whole year revenue!” you’ll say.

Guess what? Then maybe you can’t afford to hire someone to help you with SEO yet.

You should dig in, learn some SEO yourself (start here), get your revenues up, and then look at bringing someone in to help you with SEO.

Would you hire someone full time if you don’t have the revenues to pay for them? No?

Then why would you try to hire a consultant that you can’t afford?

I hate hearing stories of consultants/agencies who didn’t get paid by a client. Pretty much every consultant or agency (myself included) has at least one story of this, and unfortunately most of us have more than that.

One of most hair-raising stories I’ve read was this one by Brennan Dunn:

Do not, I repeat do not, be that client.

Why should I pay something different based on my revenue model?

Why should you pay someone more to do a job that has a higher ability to positively affect your business?

Do you pay your CFO (or yourself) more than you pay your receptionist?


Same with working with a marketing agency/consultant.

I think about paying someone like this:

Competitive rate coupled with the value they bring to your organization.

Think about this scenario:

You have two people come in with pitch decks for ways to move your company forward. You have commissioned both of these.

The first person shows you their presentation, which is not very polished design-wise. They are also not amazing at public speaking. But within the presentation they show you how they can make you an extra $2 million this year and it’s going to cost you $100,000.

The second person gives their presentation, which is incredibly polished because it was done by a designer. They are also an accomplished public speaker. They show you how they will make you $1 million and it’s going to cost you $100,000.

Now tell me. Which one would you choose?

The reality is that some of you are going to choose person number 2 because they have a better designed presentation and speak more eloquently.

Why should I pay more if my company is making more money than another company?

If your business is making more money than another and you have a bigger potential upside as well as bigger growth potential, then it will cost you more because it costs more to move the needle on something you already have going. Unless your business is a perfect well-oiled machine, more revenue can usually mean more work to get things implemented and changed in order to meaningfully move the needle on your business.

You’re paying for the value potential.

Check out the SEO calculator, and email us hello@getcredo.com if you have questions!

Looking for tool and book recommendations?

Sometimes the hardest part of growing your company is finding the right tools to use to execute on your strategies. Tools are a dime a dozen, but the right tool for the job is hard to find.

Check out our recommendations for lead generation and SEO tools as well as the books we recommend reading as you grow your business.

More Articles

When should CPG companies start investing in social ads?

Posted by on December 5, 2018 in CredoCast/Social Media

There’s a lot of advice out there about investing in social media advertising and how it’s the new wild west of advertising, with cheaper clicks…

View Post
How to diagnose a website traffic drop

Posted by on November 29, 2018 in Marketing Strategies

Has your website traffic inexplicably dropped and you have no idea why or how to fix it? A traffic drop can be a scary thing…

View Post
What is Local SEO?

Posted by on November 13, 2018 in Business

Search engine optimization is a staple in any effective digital marketing strategy. It delivers people to your site who know exactly what they want, and…

View Post